From Neglect to Nightmare: The Deadly Cost of Ignoring Fire Safety Maintenance

About Ronemus & Vilensky

The attorneys at Ronemus & Vilensky prepare every case as if it were going to trial, whether you go to trial or not. If the insurance company does not offer a fair settlement, we will be prepared to take the case to court.


With a dense population and towering apartment developments, New York City has been witness to countless fires, many caused by fire safety negligence. For an example of a preventable tragedy, look to May, 2023, when the East Flatbush neighborhood was the scene of an apartment fire at East 92nd Street.

This fire was blamed on a faulty air conditioning unit, which dropped sparks and embers into a trash pile outside the building. One person died and another severely injured; damage to property and furnishings represented a significant financial impact for building tenants.

In this guide, we will explore the negligence factors that contribute to fire risks in New York City and offer preventative tools for building owners and tenants alike.

Property Negligence Defined

Property negligence in the context of apartment and building maintenance in New York City refers to the failure of property owners, landlords, or property managers to adequately maintain their buildings in a manner that ensures the safety, health, and welfare of the occupants. This negligence can manifest in various forms, particularly in the failure to comply with local building codes,  safety regulations, and maintenance standards required by New York City laws.

Common Areas of Neglect in New York’s Apartment Developments

Key aspects of property negligence in NYC include:

1. Failure to Maintain Fire Safety Systems

  • Smoke Detectors: Not installing, maintaining, or ensuring proper functioning of smoke detectors in apartments and common areas.
  • Sprinkler Systems: Neglecting the installation, maintenance, or regular inspection of sprinkler systems as required by NYC fire codes.
  • Fire Alarms: Ignoring the installation, maintenance, or regular testing of fire alarm systems.
  • Fire Escapes: Failing to maintain accessible and unobstructed fire escapes and ensuring they meet safety standards.

2. Inadequate Structural Maintenance

  • Building Integrity: Allowing the building structure to deteriorate, resulting in unsafe conditions such as crumbling facades, unstable walls, or leaking roofs.
  • Plumbing and Electrical Systems: Failing to maintain and repair plumbing and electrical systems, leading to hazards such as water damage, mold, or electrical fires.

3. Health and Safety Violations

  • Pest Control: Neglecting pest control measures, resulting in infestations of rodents or insects that can harm residents’ health.
  • Sanitation: Failing to maintain cleanliness and sanitation in common areas, including hallways, lobbies, and garbage disposal areas.
  • Heating and Ventilation: Not providing adequate heating, ventilation, or air conditioning, leading to unhealthy living conditions.

4. Legal and Regulatory Non-Compliance

  • Building Code Violations: Ignoring requirements set forth by the NYC Department of Buildings, leading to violations and fines.
  • Tenant Safety: Failing to address safety complaints or requests for repairs from tenants in a timely and effective manner.
  • Inspection Compliance: Not adhering to mandatory inspection schedules for fire safety, elevators, boilers, and other critical systems.

Property negligence in NYC is a serious issue that not only affects the safety and well-being of residents but also carries significant legal and financial repercussions for property owners and managers.

Potential Problems – and Solutions for Building Owners or Managers

Critical fire safety devices must be in place in many different types of residential structures in NYC. In fact, regulations issued by the city government and New York City Fire Department (FDNY) require certain safety equipment to be present and functional before tenant occupancy is permitted.

It is imperative that property owners, landlords, or property managers properly install, maintain, and ensure the functionality of crucial fire safety devices.

These devices can include:

1. Self-Closing Doors

  • Installation: Failing to install self-closing doors in required areas, such as apartment entrances and stairwells, as mandated by NYC fire codes.
  • Maintenance: Neglecting to regularly inspect and repair self-closing mechanisms to ensure they function correctly during emergencies.
  • Functionality: Allowing self-closing doors to be propped open or modified in a way that compromises their effectiveness in preventing the spread of fire and smoke.

2. Smoke Detectors and Alarms

  • Installation: Not installing smoke detectors in every apartment unit, hallway, and common area as required by NYC regulations.
  • Testing and Maintenance: Failing to regularly test and replace batteries or faulty smoke detectors, compromising early fire detection.
  • Tenant Awareness: Not providing tenants with instructions on maintaining and testing their smoke detectors.

3. Sprinkler Systems

  • Installation: Ignoring the requirement to install sprinkler systems in new constructions or during significant renovations.
  • Regular Inspections: Neglecting mandatory inspections and maintenance of sprinkler systems to ensure they are operational.
  • Water Supply: Failing to maintain an adequate water supply and pressure to support the sprinkler system in case of fire.

4. Fire Extinguishers

  • Availability: Not providing fire extinguishers in accessible locations, including hallways, kitchens, and common areas.
  • Inspection and Maintenance: Failing to conduct regular inspections to ensure fire extinguishers are charged and functional.
  • Training: Not educating tenants and staff on the proper use of fire extinguishers.

5. Fire Escapes and Exit Signs

  • Accessibility: Allowing fire escapes to become obstructed or difficult to access.
  • Condition: Failing to maintain fire escapes in good condition, free from rust or structural damage.
  • Exit Signage: Not installing and maintaining illuminated exit signs to guide residents to safety during a fire.

6. Fire Alarm Systems

  • Installation: Neglecting to install comprehensive fire alarm systems that cover all areas of the building.
  • Testing and Maintenance: Failing to perform regular testing and maintenance to ensure alarm systems are fully operational.
  • Interconnection: Not ensuring that fire alarms are interconnected, allowing the entire building to be alerted in case of fire.

7. Emergency Lighting

  • Installation: Not installing emergency lighting in hallways, stairwells, and exits to guide residents during power outages or fires.
  • Maintenance: Failing to test and replace emergency lighting systems regularly.

Having adequate fire safety devices is only part of the solution; it is essential that proper installation, regular maintenance, and routine inspections of fire safety equipment are conducted to ensure the safety and well-being of residents in NYC apartment buildings.

Filing a Legal Claim Against Negligent Property Owners

If you or someone you love has been the victim of a property fire caused by the actions, inaction, or negligence of someone else, you may wish to file a legal claim. If a property owner is found negligent in a lawsuit, particularly in the context of fire safety maintenance in New York City, the consequences can be severe and multifaceted. Here are the key potential outcomes:

1. Legal Consequences

  • Compensatory Damages: The property owner may be required to compensate victims for losses incurred due to the negligence. This includes medical expenses, property damage, and lost wages.
  • Punitive Damages: In cases of gross negligence or willful misconduct, the court may impose punitive damages to punish the property owner and deter similar behavior in the future.
  • Injunctions: The court might issue an injunction requiring the property owner to take specific actions, such as making necessary repairs or improvements to ensure safety compliance.
  • Criminal Charges: In extreme cases, where negligence leads to severe injury or death, the property owner could face criminal charges, resulting in fines or imprisonment.

2. Financial Consequences

  • Increased Insurance Premiums: Following a negligence lawsuit, property insurance premiums are likely to increase, reflecting the heightened risk.
  • Property Value Decrease: The property's market value may decline due to the negative publicity and potential safety issues.
  • Repair and Compliance Costs: The owner may incur significant expenses to address the cited deficiencies and bring the property up to code.

3. Reputational Consequences

  • Negative Publicity: Media coverage of the lawsuit can damage the property owner’s reputation, impacting their ability to attract and retain tenants.
  • Tenant Relations: Current tenants may lose trust in the property owner, leading to higher turnover rates and difficulties in maintaining occupancy.
  • Business Impact: If the owner has multiple properties, the negative perception could affect their broader business operations and relationships.

Information for Apartment Fire Victims

If you have been the victim of a fire in your apartment building due to negligence on the part of the property owner, it's crucial to take several steps to protect your rights, ensure your safety, and seek appropriate compensation. Here’s a detailed guide on what to do:

Immediate Actions

1. Ensure Safety

  • Seek Medical Attention: Get immediate medical attention for any injuries. Even if you feel fine, some injuries may not be apparent right away.

2. Document the Incident

  • Photographs and Videos: Take pictures and videos of the fire damage, both inside your apartment and in common areas.
  • Your attorney can help you obtain copies of reports, medical charts, and other evidence to use in a potential legal claim.

Reporting and Legal Steps

3. Contact Authorities

  • Fire Department: Ensure the fire department has a complete report of the incident.
  • Building Inspector: Request an inspection of the building by a local building inspector to document code violations and negligence.

4. File a Report

  • Police Report: File a report with the local police department if required. This can help in legal proceedings.
  • Housing Authority: Report the negligence to the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD).

Most importantly, consult with a fire injury attorney experienced in property owner negligence cases and with a solid understanding of regulatory requirements on the part of building owners.

Call Ronemus & Vilensky Today

If you or a family member has been injured through no fault of your own, you have rights. The Law Offices of Ronemus & Vilensky, LLP, can help you exercise those rights.

Individuals injured in residential fires caused by property owner negligence, property manager neglect, or inaction related to addressing safety issues may face months or years of physical and financial trauma. To overcome these challenges, the law firm of Ronemus & Vilensky has been instrumental.

Our firm helps injury victims file claims, provides legal expertise and guidance in all phases of a claim, and ensures that the rights of injury victims are preserved. Call today for a free consultation with our personal injury experts.


Accessibility Tools